Posted by : Wendy B Monday, 30 July 2012
Of the three, The Dark Knight Rises is definitely the best, but I won’t discredit the others, as they were all necessary and they were all good in their own way. Batman Begins served the purpose of erasing the garbage that Hollywood Batman had become thanks to Joel Schumacher. The Dark Knight gave us the fall of the hero at the hands of a deadly enemy. I believe, for truer Batman fans than I, this was not a favourite film. I’ve heard complaints about it taking Batman back to the darkness and insanity that the comics have long since removed him from. But while comic fans might understand that that Batman is the past, the movie is still presenting Batman to a new group of people who haven’t been on that journey with Batman, yet. I had high “just wait and see what Nolan does” hopes for the conclusion of the trilogy and I don’t think it disappointed anyone.
Regarding Heath Ledger’s Joker in The Dark Knight, I still think he was brilliant, but I had an epiphany last night. Ledger was a brilliant villain and his performance was Oscar-worthy, but, there was one major thing missing: Batman + Joker = OTP. No, I’m not on one of my crazy ‘ship adventures. Just ask Mark Hamill, my favourite Joker. He understands that there is no Joker without Batman and no Batman without Joker. There is a bond between them that results in so many precious Batman moments, like this, my favourite. The Dark Knight had no such bond. It was an unfortunate sacrifice that had to be made to tell the overall story that Nolan wanted to tell.
On to The Dark Knight Rises: Initially, I had issue when Bane appeared doing a poor impression of Sean Connery that often required subtitles and speaker adjustments. I didn’t understand how this related at all to venom and Santa Prisca.
Then Joseph Gordon-Levitt appeared and, because he was just so damn good and because I could clearly see where his character was being led, I accepted all things. I let my brain jump off the canon train, as Nolan had wanted me to from the start, and accepted that Nolan had achieved something not easy to achieve: He created a movie for non-Batman fans. And the diehard Batman fans are okay with this. Because, while canon is out the window, it was not dumbed down or amped up ridiculously. It was a movie that worked for everyone by maintaining enough of the key elements of the canon to keep Batman fans happy, while twisting it enough to keep us guessing a bit, and still making it accessible to those who don’t know Batman at all.
Everything made sense.
My husband, with whom I often have to have “suspension of disbelief” discussions, particularly liked the way everything was completely plausible and that it wasn’t just about Batman fighting in the goofy suit with nifty gadgets. It was also about Bruce Wayne and his enemies taking him down in a very practical, pithy way. In fact, I loved that the movie addressed the fact that it wasn’t merely Batman that was necessary for Gotham, but Bruce Wayne himself, and when Bruce decided to lock himself up for eight years, the city started to fall apart. And I love that everyone but poor Gordon knew who Batman was.
I have not read Frank Miller’s Batman, but I have read No Man’s Land and Knightfall (and Kingdom Come, from which came my favourite movie moment: “So that’s what that feels like.”) There is a lot of story in those three books (and a few others), but Nolan managed to capture the critical elements to create his conclusion for Batman.
And I love that it was a conclusion. Alfred got his wish and we now have a Bruce that has moved on, while leaving the door open for the future – though I sincerely hope they do not make another movie. It’s okay to let a good thing lie, Hollywood. No matter how much more money you can make. I also don’t want to see a Justice League involving this Batman. There’s nothing about this Batman that can convince me he gives a crap about hanging out with gods, cyborgs, mutants and aliens intent on saving the world. This Batman is all about Gotham and I quite liked him that way.
Not that she didn’t handle the physical well. All the fight scenes were excellent because they were meaningful. They weren’t just about showing off Batman or Selina’s skills. They were plot advancement. It was about seeing Bruce pick himself up and return to the cowl. It was about Selina displaying her mental abilities as much as her physical prowess. It was about establishing the connection between Bruce and Selina. It was about returning hope to the people. And it was about the desperation of an already broken Batman facing Bane. None of fight the scenes were gratuitous, which limited my need to figure out the necessary button combinations involved in each battle (though I was really, really disappointed when death by exile did not involve a giant shark.)
At the end of the day, the only person running around in a goofy get up with a symbol and a silly name as Batman (and the Joker and Two-Face – both psychopaths, which says something about the company Batman keeps because of his mask). The movies made a point of how silly the outfit and name can seem, but in the end, empowered the symbol of the bat, while making it clear that it was more than the man. More than one person who saved Gotham.
My only disappointment was Talia – by no fault of her own, really. I’d like to have seen her do and be more, though I’m not sure how so in this movie. I am, unfortunately, very biased because I do not know her at all from the comics and have only really dealt with the obnoxious Arkham City version that whines for Batman and for whom I’m supposed to believe Batman was willing to sacrifice thousands of lives. At the very least, I’m glad movie Talia and Bruce weren’t Damian making, rule the world love buddies. I got the OTP I believe in. Yes, now I am shipping. Deal with it.